Defrocked Priest Committed Indefinitely to Prison for Sex Abuse Could Be Released

December 28, 2025 | By Abels & Annes, P.C.
Defrocked Priest Committed Indefinitely to Prison for Sex Abuse Could Be Released

Daniel McCormack, one of Chicago’s most notorious sex offenders in the Catholic church’s sex abuse scandal, completed his five-year sentence in 2009 after he was jailed for molesting 5 boys in Chicago’s St. Agatha Parish. At the school, he worked as a priest, teacher, and basketball coach. In addition to those 5 boys, court records show that many other boys and young men alleged that McCormick molested them in their youth while at St. Agatha Parish on Chicago’s West Side. Since his arrest, he has remained in custody at a detention facility in Illinois for sex offenders. The now-defrocked priest has been there ever since waiting to learn his fate. In 2017, Judge Dennis Porter declared McCormack a "sexually violent person" who should remain indefinitely in a state facility for sex offenders. In 2018, that was finalized and the priest was committed indefinitely to a state facility for sex offenders. This means that the state believed his crimes rose to a level that was serious enough—and he had a high enough chance of reoffending—that he should be held for life in prison. However, just recently in May 2021, an appellate court reversed the decision to hold McCormack indefinitely, saying prosecutors failed to prove that McCormack is "substantially likely to re-offend". [Read the Appeal Court Document here.]

Sex Abuse Survivors Call On Attorney General To Keep Convicted Former Chicago Priest Behind Bars

Since the appellate court reversed the life sentence, survivors of sexual abuse gathered Thursday asking for the public's help to keep the former Chicago priest in state custody. The survivors of sexual abuse at the hands of Daniel McCormack recently gave an emotional plea in which they begged prosecutors to keep him behind bars. These survivors and their supporters are planning a public campaign to encourage more abuse victims to come forward. Local legal experts, who do not represent McCormack, said the appellate court ruled that the state failed to meet its burden to prove McCormack is a significant danger to society. Technically, McCormack has served his time already and has been held beyond his sentence. But this does not mean he is definitely a free man. A spokeswoman with Illinois’ attorney general’s office said they plan to take on McCormack’s case. “We disagree with the appellate court’s decision and believe Daniel McCormack qualifies for commitment under the Sexually Violent Persons Act,” Annie Thompson said Thursday to Washington Post. “We intend to seek further review by the Illinois Supreme Court.”

What Damages Can a Sexual Abuse Victim Recover from their Abuser or the Church?

depression - Defrocked Priest Committed Indefinitely to Prison for Sex Abuse Could Be ReleasedSexual assault is not only a crime in America, but it’s also a civil issue. This means that sex abuse victims and their families can seek financial compensation from the perpetrator and any organizations that helped to facilitate or cover the crime up. This financial compensation is designed to compensate victims for any physical, emotional, and mental harm caused by the abuse. It may also cover future damages the victim will continue to suffer as a result of the sexual abuse. And as you will see below, this can be substantial since all the damage from sexual assault is not always evident immediately. The type of compensation and the amount of compensation that is available to a sexual abuse victim depends on the specific facts and circumstances of their case. Hiring an experienced sexual assault injury attorney is the best way to ensure that you are getting all the compensation you are entitled to and that future issues are being taken into consideration

Common Damages Caused by Sexual Abuse

Damages in a personal injury case refer to the costs and losses suffered by the injured party. This can include direct costs like bills, or emotional costs like PTSD or depression. Damages from sexual assault, like those that occur when a person is abused at the hands of a priest, church, or other trusted member of society, can include:
  • Medical bills, hospital stays, medications, and other medical expenses
  • Therapy and counseling treatment costs
  • Psychiatric treatment costs
  • Physical pain and suffering
  • Emotional pain and suffering
  • Lost wages from missed time from work
  • Cost of having to move to a different town or state
  • And any other reasonable costs associated with the sexual abuse
In egregious cases like sexual abuse—especially abuse involving churches—victims may also be able to recover punitive damages. Punitive damages are awarded to the abuse victim as a way to punish the responsible party or parties for their actions and to act as a warning to others that there are consequences for their actions. A good example of a situation where punitive damages may be awarded includes cases where the church or other high-ranking officials knew about the sexual assault and I either did nothing, covered it up, or otherwise helped the priest to get away with serious crimes.

Sexual Assault Survivors Have a Higher Risk of Serious Emotional Damage

In addition to the typical damages that sexual assault and sexual abuse survivors suffer, like medical bills and lost wages, many sex abuse survivors also suffer serious emotional damage. For example, sexual abuse survivors, like those who are abused by trusted members of the church while they were children. are at a much higher risk of:
  • Self-Harm and Suicide
  • Drug and Alcohol Abuse
  • Dangerous Sexually Activity and STDs
  • Depression
  • Anxiety and Panic Attack Disorders
  • Eating Disorders
  • Sleep Disorders
  • and PTSD
These serious damages that are associated with the fallout of sexual abuse by trusted members of society can be compensated in a civil lawsuit. Just like medical bills and surgery costs,  emotional damages are just as valid when it comes to seeking compensation. An experienced Chicago sexual abuse attorney can help you and your family to understand what compensation is available to you, what your best course of action may be, and explain to you all of your rights in options so that you can make the best decision possible. [Learn more: What Kind of Attorney Handles Sexual Abuse Cases?]

Abels & Annes Has a History of Successfully Handling Church Sexual Abuse Claims

In the last few years, the church has paid out tens of millions of dollars to settle lawsuits related to sexual abuse by former-priest Daniel McCormack. Some of these cases have already been closed and some lawsuits are still pending. Taking on the church—and Daniel McCormack—is nothing new for Abels and Annes. Our sexual abuse injury lawyers have decades of experience fighting for the rights of sexual assault victims so that they can get some semblance of justice and the compensation they need to move on with their lives. Our firm has helped our clients collectively recover tens of millions of dollars just from lawsuits relating to McCormack alone. Additionally, we have recovered millions more in compensation from other cases related to sexual assault in the church. If you would like to learn more about some of our verdicts and settlements related to sexual assault claims, you can view some of our case results here.