Right after a crash, most people focus on damage, injuries, and what happens next. But one big question looms large: who is liable for a car accident—the car owner or the driver? That question comes up a lot, especially when someone was driving a borrowed car, a company vehicle, or even a rental. Many people assume the driver is always responsible, but that’s not always how it works.
Sometimes, the vehicle owner is on the hook. Sometimes it’s the driver. In some situations, both may share legal responsibility. The answer depends on the facts of the accident, the relationship between the people involved, and how the law works in your state.
This blog will help clear up some of that confusion. We’ll walk through how liability is decided, when the owner might be at fault, and how insurance companies respond. You’ll also learn what to do if you’re involved in a crash involving a borrowed or shared vehicle.
If you’re dealing with an accident and unsure what steps to take, contact a car accident lawyer near you. An attorney can help sort out who should pay, what your options are, and how to pursue the money you’re owed.
What Determines Liability in a Car Accident?
Most car accident claims boil down to negligence. That’s a legal term that means someone didn’t act with reasonable care and caused harm as a result.
Basic Legal Principles of Negligence and Liability
To hold someone responsible for a crash, the law generally requires showing:
- They had a duty to drive safely.
- They breached that duty (like speeding or running a red light).
- That breach caused the accident.
- The accident led to real losses, like injuries or property damage.
Who breached that duty and caused the harm? That’s the person who usually ends up liable.
How Fault Is Established in Your State
Some states follow pure negligence rules, where the person who caused the accident pays for the damages. Others use comparative negligence, which allows both parties to share blame and split costs based on their percentage of fault.
In modified comparative negligence states, if you’re more than 50% at fault, you might be barred from recovering any money. The rules vary a lot, so check how it works where the crash happened.
Evidence Collection and Its Importance in Determining Liability
Police reports, witness statements, traffic camera footage, and vehicle damage photos help show who did what. Without evidence, it’s much harder to pin down liability.
Always collect as much as you can at the scene. This includes photos, names of witnesses, and copies of any reports. Your lawyer can help pull in missing pieces later, but the sooner you act, the better.
Who Is Legally Responsible When Someone Else Drives Your Car?
Just because someone else was behind the wheel doesn’t mean the vehicle owner is off the hook. Ownership can come with responsibilities, especially if the owner gave the driver permission.
Understanding the Doctrine of Negligent Entrustment
Negligent entrustment means you handed your keys to someone who shouldn't have been driving. That includes:
- People without a license
- Known reckless drivers
- Anyone under the influence
If you knew, or should’ve known, that the person was unsafe, the law might hold you accountable.
When Vehicle Owners Can Be Held Liable
Vehicle owners may be liable if:
- They gave permission to someone dangerous.
- The driver was their employee doing job-related tasks.
- They failed to maintain the vehicle, and that caused the accident.
Even if they weren’t in the car, they might still bear some legal blame.
When the Driver Bears Primary Responsibility
If the driver was licensed, sober, and otherwise responsible, and they caused the accident through their own bad decisions, like running a stop sign, they’ll usually carry most or all of the liability.
Can Both the Owner and Driver Be Liable for the Same Accident?
Yes. In many cases, both the owner and the driver share some blame. Here’s how that plays out.
Scenarios of Shared Liability
Let’s say a car owner lets a friend borrow their car, knowing that the friend has a suspended license. If that friend rear-ends someone, the driver’s actions caused the crash, but the owner may share fault for allowing an unlicensed driver behind the wheel.
Another example? A company car involved in an accident during a delivery. The driver may be at fault for not yielding, but the employer might also be liable for the employee’s actions on the job.
How Insurance Coverage Works When Multiple Parties Are Responsible
Most of the time, the vehicle owner’s insurance is primary. That means it covers damages first. If the driver has their own policy, that could serve as secondary insurance.
If both parties share fault, both policies may come into play. How much each pays depends on their liability limits and the laws in your state.
Examples of Shared Liability
Courts have found shared liability in:
- Parents loaning cars to reckless teen drivers
- Employers who failed to properly vet delivery drivers
- Car owners who ignored known mechanical problems
In each case, ownership brought with it a duty to act responsibly.
What Are the Insurance Implications After an Accident in Someone Else's Car?
Insurance coverage can get messy when a car isn’t driven by its owner. Who pays, and how much, depends on policy language, coverage limits, and who caused the crash.
How Primary and Secondary Insurance Coverage Works
Most of the time, the car’s insurance policy goes first. That’s primary coverage. The driver’s personal insurance may act as backup, or secondary, if the damages exceed the owner’s policy limits.
However, if the driver wasn’t listed on the policy or wasn’t allowed to drive the vehicle, the insurance company might try to deny the claim altogether.
When the Owner's Insurance Might Refuse Coverage
Car insurance companies may refuse coverage if:
- The driver was excluded from the policy.
- The vehicle was used without permission.
- The accident involved illegal activity (like a stolen car).
In those situations, the driver may have to rely on their own insurance or face personal liability.
Steps to Take If You're Involved in an Accident While Driving Someone Else's Vehicle
If you’re in a crash while driving another person’s car:
- Call the police and report the accident.
- Exchange insurance information with all involved.
- Take photos of the damage and surroundings.
- Notify the car owner and their insurer.
- Contact a lawyer to protect your rights and sort out insurance responsibilities.
Does Vehicle Ownership Automatically Create Liability?
Not always. Simply owning a car doesn’t make you responsible for everything that happens in it. But in some states, vicarious liability laws can apply.
The Concept of Vicarious Liability
Vicarious liability means one person is legally responsible for another’s actions. This can apply in family or employment situations. For example:
- A parent might be liable for their teenage driver.
- A business may be liable for an employee’s accident in a company car.
State-by-State Variations in Owner Liability Laws
Some states, such as Illinois, have automobile laws that extend liability to car owners, even when they didn’t do anything wrong. Others require proof of negligent entrustment or direct involvement. These laws change depending on where the crash happened, so local legal help matters.
Special Considerations for Company-Owned Vehicles
Companies that provide vehicles for work-related driving often bear liability for accidents involving their employees. That’s why businesses carry commercial auto insurance with higher limits than personal policies.
What Special Situations Affect Owner vs. Driver Liability?
The relationship between the owner and driver makes a big difference when figuring out liability.
Family Members Driving Your Vehicle
Some insurance policies include family members who live in the same house. If your spouse or teenager crashes your car, your policy might cover them. However, if your cousin visiting from out of town borrows your car, coverage might be limited.
Borrowed Cars vs. Rental Cars
Rental companies usually carry insurance on their vehicles. But if you crash a rental and declined extra coverage, you could end up paying out of pocket. If you loan your car to a friend, your policy is usually on the hook, even if you weren’t in the car.
When the Vehicle Was Stolen or Used Without Permission
If your car was stolen and used in a crash, most insurers won’t hold you liable. But if someone borrowed your car and you didn’t clearly say “no,” it might count as implied permission. This can open the door for legal exposure.
How Can a Personal Injury Attorney Help After an Accident?
Figuring out who’s responsible isn’t always simple, especially when multiple people or insurance policies are involved.
Here’s how a personal injury attorney can help:
- Identify all liable parties: Whether it’s the driver, owner, employer, or all three.
- Deal with the insurers: Getting compensation often means pressuring multiple companies to do the right thing.
- Investigate the facts: That includes looking into the driver’s background, history of reckless behavior, or whether permission was granted.
- Apply local law correctly: Different states follow different rules. An attorney knows which ones apply and how to use them to your benefit.
- Find every possible source of compensation: That includes primary policies, secondary policies, and even umbrella coverage.
FAQs About Car Accident Liability
Is the registered owner always liable for accidents involving their vehicle?
No. The owner isn’t automatically at fault just because they own the car. Liability depends on who caused the crash and whether the owner acted carelessly in letting someone else drive.
What happens if the driver was uninsured but the owner has insurance?
The owner’s insurance will usually cover the damages, but the company may raise rates or cancel coverage later. If the owner’s policy doesn’t apply, the driver may face personal liability.
How does liability work if I loaned my car to a friend who caused an accident?
If you gave clear permission, your insurance will likely apply. You may be responsible if your friend was unlicensed or had a known history of bad driving.
Can I be held liable if someone took my car without explicit permission?
It depends. If the person stole your car or you clearly told them not to drive it, you usually won’t be liable. But if you left your keys where they were easy to find and didn’t stop them, your insurer might argue you allowed it.
What documentation should I gather if I'm in an accident while driving someone else's car?
- Photos of all vehicles involved
- Police report number
- Insurance info for every party
- Witness names and contact info
- Notes on what happened before, during, and after the crash
How long do I have to sue someone after a car accident in Illinois?
In Illinois, you generally have two years from the date of the car accident to file a lawsuit for personal injury. If you miss this window, the court will likely dismiss your case, and you’ll lose the right to seek compensation for injuries.
Even though you may have up to two years, it’s smart to act much sooner. Evidence disappears over time, witnesses move, footage gets deleted, and vehicles get repaired. Also, insurance companies take claims more seriously when they know you’re prepared to take legal action.
Contact Our Skilled Car Accident Lawyers in Chicago Now
Evidence can disappear fast. Witnesses move. Memories fade. Acting quickly helps preserve what you need to prove fault and recover what you’re owed.
At Abels & Annes, P.C., we’ve helped people across Chicago sort out complicated car accident liability issues. We know how to hold both drivers and owners accountable and how to work with multiple insurers.
We offer a free consultation to go over your case and answer your questions. If you decide to move forward, we only get paid if we secure a settlement or a verdict on your behalf. Contact us today to get started. We’ll help you figure out where the responsibility lies and what to do next.
David Abels
Partner
David Abels has carved a niche for himself in the personal injury law sector, dedicating a substantial part of his career since 1997 to representing victims of various accidents. With a law practice that spans over two decades, his expertise has been consistently recognized within the legal community.
Author's Bio
